The Four Options for an Old 401(k)
A neutral comparison of leaving a workplace plan in place, moving it to a new employer's plan, rolling it to an IRA, or cashing it out.
Anyone who has left an employer and is deciding what to do with a workplace retirement plan balance, including those with employer stock in the plan.
The decision often gets made by default — inertia keeps the money in the old plan, or a rollover happens automatically — without the four options ever being compared side by side.
- The four general choices available for an old plan balance
- How fees and share classes can differ between options
- Why the investment menu matters as much as the fees
- How creditor protection can differ by account type and state
- How distribution flexibility and plan rules differ
- Why employer stock deserves its own conversation
- The difference between a direct and indirect transfer
- The withholding trap that catches indirect rollovers
- 1
Lay out the four general options
When leaving an employer, the four choices are generally: leave the balance in the old plan if the plan allows it, move it into a new employer's plan if that plan accepts incoming rollovers, roll it into an IRA, or take a cash distribution. Each option has different costs, investment choices, and rules, and none of them is universally correct — the right one depends on the specific plans and your own situation.
Questions to answer- · Does our old plan allow balances to remain after we leave?
- · Does a new employer's plan accept incoming rollovers?
- · What would we actually do with the money if we took a cash distribution?
- 2
Compare fees and share classes across the options
Workplace plans and IRAs can each carry administrative fees, fund expense ratios, and in some cases different share classes of the same fund with different costs. These fees are not always obvious from a quarterly statement, so requesting a written fee disclosure for each option — the old plan, the new plan, and any IRA under consideration — allows an apples-to-apples comparison.
Questions to answer- · Have we requested a fee disclosure from each plan or provider under consideration?
- · Are we comparing the same share class of any overlapping funds?
- · How do administrative fees differ between a workplace plan and an IRA?
6 more sections in the full guide.
Here is exactly what is still to come. Add your name and email above to keep reading on this page and print a copy. Two fields — never account balances or account numbers.
- Look closely at what each option can actually invest in
A workplace plan typically offers a limited, pre-selected investment menu, while an IRA generally opens a much broader range of investment choices.
Includes: “What does the old plan's investment menu actually contain?”
- Understand creditor protection differences
Workplace retirement plans generally receive strong federal creditor protection, while IRA creditor protection can depend on state law and the circumstances involved, such as bankruptcy versus other claims.
Includes: “Does creditor protection matter to our specific situation?”
- Compare distribution flexibility and plan-specific rules
Some workplace plans allow penalty-free withdrawals at an earlier age than IRAs do under certain separation-from-service rules, while IRAs may offer more flexible ongoing withdrawal options once distributions begin.
Includes: “Does our current plan offer an early-withdrawal exception that an IRA would not?”
- Ask about employer stock and net unrealized appreciation before deciding
If the plan holds employer stock, a specific tax treatment called net unrealized appreciation may allow some of the stock's growth to be taxed at capital gains rates rather than ordinary income rates under certain conditions.
Includes: “Does our plan hold employer stock, and how much has it appreciated?”
- Understand the difference between a direct and indirect rollover
A direct rollover moves funds straight from one plan or custodian to another without passing through your hands, while an indirect rollover pays the funds to you first, after which you generally have a limited window to redeposit the full amount to avoid it being treated as a taxable distribution.
Includes: “Is the transfer we're planning structured as direct or indirect?”
- Watch for the mandatory withholding trap on indirect rollovers
When a workplace plan pays a distribution directly to you, it is generally required to withhold a portion for federal taxes, which means the check you receive is smaller than your full balance.
Includes: “If this becomes an indirect rollover, do we understand the withholding amount?”
No spam. We never sell or share your details, and you can ask us to stop contacting you at any time.
Official sources
Rules change. Confirm anything that affects a decision against the current official source.
Where this fits in our work
This guide accompanies our 401(k) & ira rollovers work. Joe Donti meets with Arizona households by appointment — in the Scottsdale office, by phone, or on Zoom.
Related reading
- Retirement Planning
SECURE Act 2.0: Six Changes Retirees Should Actually Care About
- Financial Planning
Fee-Only vs Commission-Based Financial Advisors in Scottsdale: What the Difference Actually Costs You
- Financial Planning
How to Choose a Financial Advisor in Arizona: 7 Questions Every Retiree Should Ask
This guide is general education and is not individualized investment, tax, legal, Medicare, or insurance advice, and it is not a recommendation to buy or sell any product or security. Investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal. Insurance and annuity guarantees depend on the claims-paying ability of the issuing carrier. Rules and figures change — confirm current details with the official sources above and with your own tax, legal, or insurance professional.